Before You Suffocate Your Own Fool Self
by Danielle EvansRiverhead, 240 pp., 2010
Reviewed by Jessica Hindman
“Me and Jasmine and Michael were hanging out at Mr. Thompson’s pool” (1). So begins “Virgins,” the first story in Danielle Evans’s Before You Suffocate Your Own Fool Self, a brilliant debut collection that showcases Evan’s stunning ability to unearth racial and sexual complexities with deceptively casual language. In this first sentence, Evans creates a setting that could not seem more blasé: three teenagers “hanging out” by a pool. But under the surface of suburban normalcy, racial and sexual dangers lurk. As the story progresses, we find out that the seemingly simple act of lounging by Mr. Thompson’s pool is in fact a result of complex racial, sexual, and class hierarchies:
Mr. Thompson was retired, but he used to be our elementary school principal, which is how he was the only person in Mount Vernon we knew with a swimming pool in his backyard. We—and everybody else we knew—lived on the south side, where it was mostly apartment buildings, and if you had a house, you were lucky if your backyard was big enough for a plastic kiddie pool. (6)
In other words, Mr. Thompson is offering a favor to the lower-class narrator—Erica—and her friends. And despite their young age, Erica and Jasmine are already wary of male favors:
“We hung out with [Michael] because we figured it was easier to have a boy around than not to…When you were alone, men were always wanting something from you. We even wondered about Mr. Thompson sometimes, or at least we never went swimming at his house without Michael with us.” (6)
Evans is so subtle in establishing the dangers that surround her characters that the reader barely notices as she slowly raises the stakes. When the three teens decide to use their fake IDs to go clubbing in New York City, the danger seems more of the suburban variety (getting caught by their parents) than the late-night-news variety (rape or murder). But as the story progresses, the two types of dangers—the urban and the suburban—become increasingly conflated. At the end of “Virgins,” neither Erica nor Jasmine is still a virgin, but Erica has lost her virginity in a familiar suburban setting, while Jasmine has disappeared to have sex with strangers in the Bronx. The move from the suburban to urban and back, however, is ultimately inconsequential; neither of the girls has encountered sex in a safe, premeditated, or fulfilling way. Here Evans demonstrates the absurdity of presuming that the suburbs offer black teenagers a safer alternative to the city. The girls’ parents are working so many shifts (presumably to afford a suburban existence) that they fail to notice their daughters’ transgressions. And even though no one in the story says so directly, we know implicitly that the sexual stakes for white girls in this suburb are much lower than they are for Crystal and Jasmine.
Indeed, Evans’s writing is at its strongest when she shows how typical suburban high jinks swiftly become more ominous when the characters in question are minorities. The story, “Robert E. Lee Is Dead,” follows the relationship between Geena—a popular cheerleader who gets kicked off the squad for low grades—and her friend Crystal, who has managed to become valedictorian despite the school’s racial prejudice. When Geena asks Crystal to participate in a senior prank, Crystal points out that “White kids do senior pranks. When we try it, they’re called felonies” (220). Crystal ends up participating in the prank anyway, but when the prank gets out of hand and the two girls accidentally set the school football field on fire, Geena insists on taking the blame. The last image of the story is of Crystal running from the scene of the crime:
“I stared at Geena for a long second. Then I took off running, stopping in the middle of the parking lot to take off my heels. I kept running, the asphalt stinging my feet through my panty hose. Halfway up the hill behind the school, I stopped to look back, vaguely recalling Sunday school and Lot’s wife turning into a pillar of salt. Already I could hear sirens in the distance. I watched Geena sitting on the curb beside the pay phone, fists curled backward into cushions for her chin. She looked small and still and ready. I turned then, shut my eyes, and ran breathlessly toward the dam. I didn’t stop again until I had crossed the bridge and hopped the fence that took me back to Eastdale. On the other side, I stopped to catch my breath, and then kept running, knowing even then that a better person would have turned around.” (229)
At the core of this story, and the entire collection, is a moral question: How can blacks who have attained academic and worldly success live in a world where too many black teenagers literally get left behind on a curb? Evans prose here is stunning in its ability to show the pain of separation that occurs in the suburbs when upwardly mobile black youth leave their less fortunate friends to deal with the all-too-familiar consequences of racial inequality. Indeed, the title of the collection comes from a Donna Kate Rushin poem, which Evans includes as an epigraph to the book. In the poem, Rushin writes, “I’m sick of mediating with your worst self/On behalf of your better selves.” Evans’s stories are masterful portraits of characters who want to become their “better selves,” but who, for many reasons—racism, sexism, guilt about the others who are left behind while they enjoy newfound success—are never quite satisfied with their progress.


